CORNWALL Council is "not fit for purpose", parish councillors and representatives from across the county declared following a heated three-hour meeting last week.
Representatives of more than a dozen parish councils stretching from Gweek to Carlyon Bay packed a hall in Chacewater in response to a letter sent in July by Chacewater Parish Council to all 213 town and parish councils outlining its criticisms of Cornwall Council.
In the letter, also published in the West Briton, Chacewater branded the unitary authority an "emerging dictatorship" and attacked its lack of communication, savings plans, planning policy, arm's-length organisations and highly paid officers.
At the highly-charged meeting on Tuesday, fellow parish councillors agreed and declared change must happen at Cornwall Council.
More militant members called for the local government ombudsman to be called in, for the formation of an alliance of parish councils and even for protests to take place at the doors of County Hall – but after declaring Cornwall Council "not fit for purpose" the decision was taken to draft a further letter, to be agreed by the councils which attended, before firing it off to Cornwall Council's chief executive Andrew Kerr, leader John Pollard, elected members and all town and parish councils. They also hope the letter will win them the backing of the county's MPs and the media.
A further meeting is to be staged in north Cornwall as the uprising gathers momentum.
Truro city councillor Armorel Carlyon, who chaired the meeting despite her own council not endorsing what has become known as the 'Chacewater Letter', told those gathered in the hall that she could see "democratically elected members being airbrushed out of the picture" by non-elected council officers. Housing schemes were "totally out of scale for Cornwall and they are moving in on the greenfield sites", she said.
Orlando Kimber, from the Cornwall branch of the Campaign to Protect Rural England, told the meeting: "The pain you are feeling is felt by many others," adding that when it came to planning policy "people aren't listening to us either at local or national government".
Speakers reeled off a list of complaints, among them a lack of devolved and appropriately funded services to parish councils, disregard for the localism agenda, lack of transparency, the tendering process of the council's arm's-length contractor Cormac, the role of planning officers and the county's waste policy.
Also high on the list were accusations of elected members being "shunned by officers"; the role of the council's 19 community network managers, condemned as a waste of time and money; the barrage of housing schemes and developments despite local opposition; and the second homes scandal, whereby owners can 'flip' their properties – exploiting a loophole to avoid paying council tax or business rates by declaring them as holiday lets, but with income below the threshold for the rates.
Mike Burden, from Mylor Parish Council, said: "I find it extraordinary that after moving to a unitary council and removing one tier of local government, more services are not being devolved down to parish councils."
Nigel Hennell, from Budock Parish Council, which for two years has been fighting plans by Midas to build 150 homes in the area, said: "Rural parishes are being ignored."
Linda Lang, a St Austell Bay parish councillor, said they did not feel they were part of the drive towards localism: "We need to have some sort of indication from Cornwall Council as to how they might work in partnership with ourselves with appropriate funding – none of this stuff of, 'You do it but there's no money'.
"The attitude of planning officers often seems to disregard the opinions of the parish councils who have a mandate to express the opinions and wishes of their electorate."
Kevin Bennetts, campaigner and member of the Newlyn Pier and Harbour Commissioners, condemned the Stadium for Cornwall scheme as a "Trojan horse" set to intrude on the Kenwyn valley, and branded the authority's planners "out of control, because they are not serving in the interests of the people". Referring to the Scottish referendum, he said: "There's a huge window of opportunity to grab localism and make it our own, take control of our destiny and put it back in our own hands."
Ashley Wood, from Lanner Parish Council, said the blame should be laid at central government's door before calling for an audit of the unitary authority and Cormac.
"Cornwall Council is the wrong set-up for Cornwall," he said. "In some places unitary works, but because of our geography it's impossible for Cornwall Council to work properly."
However, campaigner Ken Rickard attacked the waste of taxpayers' money, citing the £25 million loan from Cornwall Council to Sita to build the incinerator at St Dennis, up to £13 million to build the road to it and the £20 million that would be saved by cancelling the contract and raising recycling rates.
Mr Rickard said: "No one seems to have control over the finances at County Hall. The finance people are not fit for purpose and the waste disposal and the legal team are not fit for purpose."
Gwennap parish councillor David Lanyon questioned the point of writing a letter.
"The whole system doesn't work," he said. "It's what we do collectively from this day on, not whether we tell Mr Pollard how poorly he's allowing his 'shower' to operate. He knows it already. It's not going to be effective."
![Parish Council uprising against Cornwall Council Parish Council uprising against Cornwall Council]()